A Comprehensive Comparative Analysis of Emotional Support Delivery by NAO Robots and Humans Across Varied Emotional States
RME 4211 · Human Robot Interaction Lab, University of Dhaka · Aug – Nov 2023
Supervised by Dr. Lafifa Jamal and Shifat E Arman
In short
Can a small humanoid robot comfort someone as well as a person can? We programmed NAO to respond to three emotions and designed a study that scores robot and human support side by side.
- 3emotional states: happiness, sadness and fear
- 2support sources compared: NAO robot vs. human
- 5measures: impact, comfort, clarity, satisfaction, preference

Motivation
Social robots are increasingly proposed as companions in care settings, but it is unclear how their emotional support compares with a human's. This project measures that gap directly, using the same emotional situations and the same questionnaire for both sources of support.
What we built
- Emotion-specific behavioursWe programmed NAO with response behaviours for happiness, sadness and fear, so the robot reacts appropriately to each emotional state.
- Study protocolParticipants experience support from both NAO and a human. Informed consent, an observer present at all times and a controlled, distraction-free room keep the sessions safe and comparable.
- QuestionnaireA structured questionnaire scores each session on emotional impact, comfort, communication clarity, overall satisfaction and personal preference.
Analysis
Scores for NAO and human support are compared per emotion to find where the robot is competitive, where it falls short, and what would make robotic emotional support more effective.
Demos
Tools: NAO humanoid robot, Google Forms